Findings · Original analysis · 1986–2026

Is the wave at La Saladita changing? Forty years of satellite shorelines and eleven years of whitewater.

The waterline at the break itself has not moved beyond the noise since 1986, and the whitewater at the point shows no detectable shift: adjusted for swell, wind and tide it sits about 8 m farther out since February 2024 than in the two years before (95% interval −10 to +16 m), inside ordinary year-to-year change. The shoreline that moved is at the north end of the beach, past where the wave ends: Z6 North beach has retreated up to about 0.7 m a year for forty years, and the unwalled beach right next to it, Z7a Near northwest, about 0.5 m a year, so the retreat belongs to that end of the beach and reaches past its walls. Farther away, Z7c Far northwest and the southeast beach changed little (about 0.1 m a year).

Stretches. This page describes the shoreline by stretch only. It does not identify individual properties or structures, and nothing here assigns cause or blame.

Zones. Places on the beach are named by neutral zones, Z1 South point to Z7 Northwest beach (split into Z7a Near northwest, Z7b Middle northwest and Z7c Far northwest), by location only. Zone map and table.

Note, 5 November 2026. For Aug–Sep 2026 against the 2016–2025 seasonal position, see The high sea of 2026 (30 October 2026).

Landsat 5/7/8/9 and Sentinel-2 · 443 + 348 clear shorelines · 467 whitewater images · 151 transects over 6.6 km · 27 September 2026
Whitewater edge at the point,
since Feb 2024 vs the two years before, swell-adjusted
+7.8 m
95% −10.0 to +16.2 · not detected (Météo-France forcing, 2021–26)
Z6 North beach, central stretch:
waterline 1986–2026
−0.69 m/yr
95% Monte Carlo −0.90 to −0.50 · E1
The wave stretch (Z1–Z5) and the
open-beach controls, 1986–2026
−0.10 · −0.13 · −0.13
m/yr: Z1–Z5 · SE · Z7c far northwest — all within noise
Uncertainty of one satellite
waterline (median σ)
15.4 m
conservative: internal 9.7 m + a 12 m method floor from the literature · smallest wall effect one transect can show in 2 years ≈ 17.9 m

The question: has human shoreline modification changed the morphology that creates La Saladita's wave, beyond what storms and natural variability explain? This season palms at the waterline fell over in a storm, and hotels and restaurants have put down boulders, rock walls and decks on concrete pillars. The worry is that the walls and boulders starve the beach, change the bottom and change the wave.

Satellites cannot see the sea floor in a turbid, foamy surf zone, and they cannot measure a wave's peel angle or how long a section runs. What they can measure, every few days since 1986, is where the water meets the sand, and since 2015 where the whitewater sits. Two things are kept apart: beach state (waterline position, beach width, storm steps and recovery) and surf-break state (the position of the whitewater at the point, adjusted for the swell). There is no combined index. Detection comes first — is anything changing? — and only then the question of what caused it.

Every claim carries an evidence level: E0 observation, E1 association, E2 timing consistent with a cause, E3 counterfactual support (dated treatment, passed placebos), E4 physical mechanism measured, E5 the wave itself shown to change, E6 replication. For the shoreline this satellite record can reach E3–E4 at most, and only once wall dates exist. It cannot reach E5. Nothing here says a wall "changed the wave".

1 · Surf-break state

Allowing for the swell, the whitewater at the point shows no detectable shift

Finding · E0

Adjusted for swell, wind and tide, the whitewater edge at the point sits +7.8 m farther out since February 2024 than from October 2021 to January 2024 (95% interval −10.0 to +16.2 m): no detectable shift.

131 Sentinel-2 images from October 2021 to September 2026 show whitewater at the point and pass the image screen: one image per acquisition (ESA re-issued many scenes when it reprocessed the archive; the latest processing is kept), and no sun glint, haze or cloud over the surf zone or the water just beyond it. Glint matters here because it is more common after 2024 (about half the images, against about a third before) and it brightens the sea enough to push the detected foam edge seaward. Without the screen, 255 images give +8.7 m (−9.3 to +18.9); a looser glint threshold gives +8.0 m (−13.8 to +21.7). No version detects a shift. The seaward edge of the foam is regressed on a step at 1 February 2024 plus the swell at the overpass hour from the Météo-France wave model at the grid point nearest the break (height, height squared, mean period, direction), wind and the site tide; the interval comes from resampling whole calendar years. Swell is not taken from ERA5 across 2024: its wave record steps down on 1 February 2024, about 9% lower wave height and 0.5 s shorter mean period at the offshore node, against two independent wave models (Météo-France and DWD) that agree with each other across that date. Three NDBC buoys off California show ERA5 is the product that moved, and the step appears from the equator to California. Over the full Sentinel-2 record, 2015–2026, with ERA5 adjusted for the step and before the image screen, the shift is about +14 m (permutation over years p = 0.089). Half-year effects range from −25 m to +23 m with no lasting shift.

What this means for detection: a test that uses the year as its unit cannot call a single post-event year significant until there are 19 reference years of Sentinel-2 images, around 2034; with three recent years against five, a shift of about 28–40 m is needed for 80% power. Satellites alone cannot see a moderate change at the break for about a decade. A measured baseline of the bottom now is what makes a change detectable.

2 · Beach state

The wave stretch held its waterline; the north end of the beach did not

Shoreline change rate per transect, 1986–2026 Sentinel-2 image of the coast with one line per transect. Red = the waterline moved landward, blue = seaward; gray = the 95% interval includes zero. T000 · -3000 m · −0.07 m/yr (−0.28 to +0.12) T001 · -2950 m · −0.09 m/yr (−0.30 to +0.14) T002 · -2900 m · −0.11 m/yr (−0.33 to +0.11) T003 · -2850 m · −0.12 m/yr (−0.34 to +0.09) T004 · -2800 m · −0.12 m/yr (−0.35 to +0.09) T005 · -2750 m · −0.07 m/yr (−0.30 to +0.18) T006 · -2700 m · −0.10 m/yr (−0.37 to +0.21) T007 · -2650 m · −0.10 m/yr (−0.48 to +0.29) T008 · -2600 m · −0.06 m/yr (−0.54 to +0.52) T009 · -2550 m · −0.81 m/yr (−1.78 to +0.19) T010 · -2500 m · +2.64 m/yr (+1.69 to +3.25) T011 · -2450 m · +0.22 m/yr (−0.00 to +0.47) T012 · -2400 m · −0.03 m/yr (−0.23 to +0.18) T013 · -2350 m · −0.14 m/yr (−0.34 to +0.06) T014 · -2300 m · −0.16 m/yr (−0.36 to +0.03) T015 · -2250 m · −0.21 m/yr (−0.40 to −0.01) T016 · -2200 m · −0.18 m/yr (−0.37 to +0.01) T017 · -2150 m · −0.18 m/yr (−0.38 to +0.02) T018 · -2100 m · −0.20 m/yr (−0.39 to −0.01) T019 · -2050 m · −0.20 m/yr (−0.38 to −0.01) T020 · -2000 m · −0.15 m/yr (−0.34 to +0.03) T021 · -1950 m · −0.19 m/yr (−0.39 to −0.01) T022 · -1900 m · −0.19 m/yr (−0.38 to −0.01) T023 · -1850 m · −0.23 m/yr (−0.43 to −0.05) T024 · -1800 m · −0.21 m/yr (−0.39 to −0.01) T025 · -1750 m · −0.17 m/yr (−0.37 to −0.00) T026 · -1700 m · −0.14 m/yr (−0.34 to +0.03) T027 · -1650 m · −0.08 m/yr (−0.26 to +0.11) T028 · -1600 m · −0.07 m/yr (−0.27 to +0.11) T029 · -1550 m · −0.04 m/yr (−0.23 to +0.16) T030 · -1500 m · −0.07 m/yr (−0.28 to +0.12) T031 · -1450 m · +0.00 m/yr (−0.18 to +0.20) T032 · -1400 m · +0.04 m/yr (−0.15 to +0.22) T033 · -1350 m · −0.00 m/yr (−0.21 to +0.18) T034 · -1300 m · +0.10 m/yr (−0.09 to +0.28) T035 · -1250 m · −0.04 m/yr (−0.24 to +0.14) T036 · -1200 m · −0.06 m/yr (−0.26 to +0.11) T037 · -1150 m · −0.10 m/yr (−0.30 to +0.09) T038 · -1100 m · +0.00 m/yr (−0.19 to +0.19) T039 · -1050 m · +0.00 m/yr (−0.22 to +0.22) T040 · -1000 m · −0.08 m/yr (−0.28 to +0.11) T041 · -950 m · −0.31 m/yr (−0.51 to −0.11) T042 · -900 m · −0.18 m/yr (−0.38 to +0.02) T043 · -850 m · −0.21 m/yr (−0.40 to −0.03) T044 · -800 m · −0.17 m/yr (−0.36 to +0.04) T045 · -750 m · −0.19 m/yr (−0.38 to +0.01) T046 · -700 m · −0.18 m/yr (−0.39 to +0.00) T047 · -650 m · +0.04 m/yr (−0.14 to +0.23) T048 · -600 m · −0.07 m/yr (−0.25 to +0.11) T049 · -550 m · −0.01 m/yr (−0.20 to +0.19) T050 · -500 m · +0.06 m/yr (−0.15 to +0.27) T051 · -450 m · −0.43 m/yr (−0.67 to −0.21) T052 · -400 m · −0.56 m/yr (−0.83 to −0.24) T053 · -350 m · +1.25 m/yr (+0.75 to +1.78) T054 · -300 m · +0.56 m/yr (−0.10 to +1.12) T055 · -250 m · +0.35 m/yr (+0.02 to +0.65) T056 · -225 m · +0.35 m/yr (−0.00 to +0.63) T057 · -200 m · +0.33 m/yr (−0.00 to +0.60) T058 · -175 m · +0.14 m/yr (−0.24 to +0.44) T059 · -150 m · −0.04 m/yr (−0.44 to +0.30) T060 · -125 m · +0.05 m/yr (−0.32 to +0.39) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z6 · zone median −0.53 m/yr (19 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7a · zone median −0.50 m/yr (15 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7b · zone median −0.27 m/yr (27 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7c · zone median −0.14 m/yr (29 transects) Z7a near northwest Z7b middle northwest Z7c far northwest -2000 m Z1 south point +0 m +1000 m +2000 m +3000 m
Waterline change per transect, 1986–2026. 151 shore-normal transects every 50 m, every 25 m over parts of Z5, Z6 and Z7b (the map draws Z6 and Z7 every 50 m), on a Sentinel-2 image of 2026-02-22. Red = retreat, blue = advance, thick = the 95% Monte Carlo interval excludes zero, gray = it does not. In Z6 and Z7 every line takes its zone’s color, from the zone’s median rate, not its own. Hover a line for its rate (in Z6 and Z7, the zone median). Distances are along the shore from arc 0, at the south end of Z6 North beach (+ = northwest, toward La Unión; − = southeast, toward the point). Z7a, Z7b and Z7c are labeled on the sea side. The zone map shows where each zone starts and ends.
Finding · E1

The north end of the beach retreated walled or not, while the wave stretch and the far beaches held their waterline. Over 1986–2026 the wave stretch (Z1–Z5) moved −0.10 m/yr (−0.28 to +0.09) and the open-beach controls, Z7c Far northwest and the southeast beach, −0.13 m/yr each: no trend beyond the noise. The Z6 central stretch retreated −0.69 m/yr (−0.90 to −0.50) and the unwalled beach right next to it, Z7a Near northwest, −0.48 m/yr (−0.66 to −0.30).

About 28 m of retreat in front of the central stretch of Z6 since the mid-1980s, well above twice the per-image noise. Z7a has no walls reported and its interval overlaps the central stretch’s, so the retreat is a property of that end of the beach (the creek enters about 300 m to the south, in Z5 Creek mouth) and not by itself evidence that the walls caused it. The walls were most likely built because this stretch was retreating (the selection hypothesis, H3, below). Farther northwest the rate falls off: the Z7b stretch, in Z7b Middle northwest, moved −0.31 m/yr (−0.51 to −0.14), about the same as the rest of Z7b (−0.20 to −0.36 m/yr per transect), and Z7c, from 2.2 km on, −0.13 m/yr as a whole, within the noise, with a few of its transects near −0.2 to −0.3 m/yr.

Annual waterline position, 1986–2026 Four lines of annual median waterline position relative to each reach’s own average: the Z6 central stretch, Z7a Near northwest, the wave stretch Z1–Z5, and the controls (southeast beach and Z7c Far northwest). Up = seaward. −15.0 m −10.0 m −5.0 m 0 m +5.0 m +10.0 m +15.0 m +20.0 m 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 ↑ seaward Z6 central stretch · 1986: +18.7 m Z6 central stretch · 1990: +7.8 m Z6 central stretch · 1992: +10.2 m Z6 central stretch · 1993: +2.6 m Z6 central stretch · 1994: +6.7 m Z6 central stretch · 1995: +9.1 m Z6 central stretch · 1996: +12.9 m Z6 central stretch · 1997: +5.8 m Z6 central stretch · 1998: +5.2 m Z6 central stretch · 1999: +9.2 m Z6 central stretch · 2000: +11.1 m Z6 central stretch · 2001: +8.3 m Z6 central stretch · 2002: +7.4 m Z6 central stretch · 2003: +3.1 m Z6 central stretch · 2009: +0.1 m Z6 central stretch · 2013: −1.6 m Z6 central stretch · 2014: +3.5 m Z6 central stretch · 2015: −10.6 m Z6 central stretch · 2016: −4.3 m Z6 central stretch · 2017: −7.8 m Z6 central stretch · 2018: −10.9 m Z6 central stretch · 2019: −8.7 m Z6 central stretch · 2020: −9.7 m Z6 central stretch · 2021: −11.8 m Z6 central stretch · 2022: −11.6 m Z6 central stretch · 2023: −13.2 m Z6 central stretch · 2024: −8.8 m Z6 central stretch · 2025: −9.7 m Z6 central stretch · 2026: −14.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 1986: +4.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 1990: +13.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 1992: +8.2 m Z7a Near northwest · 1993: +10.4 m Z7a Near northwest · 1994: +7.3 m Z7a Near northwest · 1995: +8.8 m Z7a Near northwest · 1996: +9.4 m Z7a Near northwest · 1997: +0.8 m Z7a Near northwest · 1998: +0.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 1999: +7.0 m Z7a Near northwest · 2000: +6.0 m Z7a Near northwest · 2001: +4.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 2002: +2.1 m Z7a Near northwest · 2003: +5.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2009: −2.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 2013: −3.3 m Z7a Near northwest · 2014: −3.0 m Z7a Near northwest · 2015: −6.6 m Z7a Near northwest · 2016: −6.0 m Z7a Near northwest · 2017: −5.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2018: −9.3 m Z7a Near northwest · 2019: −7.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2020: −6.5 m Z7a Near northwest · 2021: −5.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2022: −5.1 m Z7a Near northwest · 2023: −7.2 m Z7a Near northwest · 2024: −5.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2025: −3.9 m Z7a Near northwest · 2026: −9.1 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1986: +3.6 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1990: +5.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1992: +0.7 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1993: +1.9 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1994: +1.1 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1995: +4.4 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1996: +2.9 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1997: −1.7 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1998: −2.2 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 1999: +2.2 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2000: +1.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2001: +0.6 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2002: +2.7 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2003: +3.1 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2009: −2.8 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2013: +2.1 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2014: +0.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2015: −4.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2016: −3.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2017: −1.2 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2018: −3.2 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2019: −2.9 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2020: +0.6 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2021: −1.4 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2022: −1.2 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2023: −3.6 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2024: +1.0 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2025: −0.7 m Controls (SE, Z7c) · 2026: −4.2 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1986: −5.0 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1990: +1.1 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1992: −1.5 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1993: −0.2 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1994: +1.8 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1995: +2.0 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1996: +4.1 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1997: +1.0 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1998: −1.8 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 1999: +5.4 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2000: +4.2 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2001: +6.1 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2002: +4.3 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2003: −0.3 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2009: −7.6 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2013: −0.0 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2014: +0.4 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2015: −2.3 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2016: −0.6 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2017: +0.0 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2018: −4.4 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2019: −2.8 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2020: −1.1 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2021: +2.8 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2022: +1.4 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2023: −2.4 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2024: −1.2 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2025: −2.9 m The wave (Z1–Z5) · 2026: −4.5 m Controls (SE, Z7c) The wave (Z1–Z5) Z7a Near northwest Z6 central stretch
Annual median waterline, each reach relative to its own 1986–2026 average (tide- and setup-corrected; Landsat 1986–2015, Landsat + Sentinel-2 from December 2015; years with at least three clear shorelines). Up = seaward. Orange: the Z6 central stretch (−0.69 m/yr). Violet: Z7a Near northwest (−0.48 m/yr). Blue: the controls, the mean of the southeast beach and Z7c Far northwest (−0.13 m/yr each). Green: the wave stretch, Z1–Z5 (−0.10 m/yr).
ReachTransectsRate 1986–2026 (m/yr)95% MC intervalRate 2016–2026, S2 (m/yr)95% MC interval
The wave, Z1 South point to Z5 Creek mouth23−0.10−0.28 to +0.09−0.05−0.85 to +0.74
Z5 Creek mouth9+0.28−0.06 to +0.55−0.19−1.17 to +0.87
Z6, central stretch4−0.69−0.90 to −0.50−0.30−1.28 to +0.70
Z6, central stretch (wider group)5−0.69−0.89 to −0.50−0.25−1.25 to +0.77
Z6 stretch (one zone-level group; combined fit not computed yet)8————
Z7a Near northwest, without walls, 0.45–1.15 km NW of the cove15−0.48−0.66 to −0.30+0.08−0.68 to +0.91
Z7b stretch5−0.31−0.51 to −0.14+0.27−0.55 to +1.16
Z7c Far northwest, control without walls, ≥ 2.2 km NW29−0.13−0.31 to +0.05+0.51−0.33 to +1.31
Southeast beach (outside the zones), control without walls, 1.5–3 km SE (toward Troncones)31−0.13−0.32 to +0.04−0.06−0.87 to +0.75

Rates are Theil–Sen slopes of annual medians; intervals come from 1,000 Monte Carlo draws of tide error, slope, wave setup and georegistration with images resampled within each year. Ten-year Sentinel-2 rates have wide intervals: ten points of a seasonal, storm-kicked series cannot pin a rate below about ±0.7 m/yr.

3 · Storms and recovery

Storm steps are small next to the noise, and the record sees them late

Finding · E0

None of the 10 energetic events and tropical cyclones since 2016 (below the site's 99th percentile of wave power) moved any reach's median waterline by more than twice its uncertainty in the first clear image after it. Latest image, 2026-09-10: the wave stretch (Z1–Z5) −6.0 m, the Z6 central stretch −1.3 m, the far-northwest control, Z7c, −13.0 m against their 2026 dry-season median: wet-season lows, and larger at the open-beach control than on the wave stretch. Part of that is water, not sand: in August and September 2026 the sea stood about 21 to 23 cm above its normal level for those months (El Niño; measured at the Zihuatanejo tide gauge), which by itself moves the waterline about 4 to 6 m landward on beaches this flat. The tide correction here covers the astronomical tide only. At any one transect a single image places the waterline to within about 10 m at best (this page uses a conservative 15.4 m), so single-image values like these are indicative.

Clouds hide the coast through most of the rainy season, so the first clear image after a storm often comes weeks later, after part of the recovery. No reach had a landward step beyond the noise with images after it, so no recovery time can be fitted and recovery with and without walls cannot be compared from these events. The 26 events since 2016 above the site's 99th percentile of daily wave power (39.6 kW/m, ERA5), which include the largest tropical-cyclone swells, are analyzed separately; images from 21 September 2026 on are not included.

Event (start · storm)Peak wave power (kW/m)Z6 central stretch (m)Wave stretch, Z1–Z5 (m)Controls, SE beach + Z7c (m)Z7b stretch (m)
2017-09-12 · Max, Norma31.7−9.5−4.2−3.3—
2017-10-05 · southern swell38.2−2.2−3.7−6.5−10.2
2019-09-29 · Narda28.8−1.9−1.7−6.3−13.2
2020-07-07 · Cristina27.8+0.1−0.1+3.5+8.8
2020-09-29 · Marie26.9−2.6+0.9−3.2−3.4
2021-08-17 · southern swell35.7−5.3+2.0+1.8−0.3
2022-10-22 · Roslyn26.0−3.6+2.7−5.9−1.5
2023-06-30 · Beatriz26.1+4.2+7.5+10.1+11.6
2023-09-03 · Jova28.7−0.1−0.1−3.0−4.6
2023-10-20 · Norma29.2+1.0−0.1−2.2+1.8

Step = first clear Sentinel-2 image within 30 days after the event minus the median of images in the 45 days before; * = larger than twice that reach’s uncertainty. Events: ERA5 daily wave power above its 1979–2026 95th percentile (top 40% of those) or a HURDAT2 tropical cyclone within 800 km, excluding days above the 99th percentile.

4 · The walls and the decks

What the satellites can say about the walls

Selection before effect (H3) · E1

Against ten transects without walls chosen for similar orientation, seasonality and storm response, the Z6 central stretch lost −0.49 m/yr more (−0.62 to −0.37) over 1986–2026; the placebo test cannot be run: its correlation cluster is Z6 North beach itself and holds no eligible site without walls of the same width (k = 0). Within the Sentinel-2 years the gap stopped widening after about 2021.

That is the pattern the selection hypothesis predicts — the stretch was retreating before anyone built walls on it — and also the pattern of a wall that holds the line once built (the gap's rate went from −2.44 to +1.08 m/yr around 2021; the hinge beats a straight line by leave-one-year-out error only narrowly). Without the date each wall went in, the two cannot be told apart. An event study needs each wall's date, fixed from dated imagery before the outcome is read.

SiteGap vs similar controls 1986–2026 (m/yr)95% CIPlacebo p exact (k sites)Gap 2016–2026, S2 (m/yr)95% CI (year blocks)Placebo p exact (k)Synthetic-control pre-fit RMSE (m)
Z6 central stretch (wall)−0.49−0.62 to −0.37— (k = 0)−0.21−1.08 to +0.36— (k = 0)4.4
Z6 stretch (one zone-level group; combined fit not computed yet)———————
Z7b stretch−0.12−0.22 to −0.040.333 (k = 17†)−0.10−0.42 to +0.290.722 (k = 17†)1.4

Gap = the site's annual waterline minus the mean of ten similarity-matched transects without walls (negative = the site lost ground relative to them). Placebo p = (1 + number of same-width sites without walls in the same correlation cluster with a gap at least as large) ÷ (1 + k). † = fewer than the 19 sites the test calls for: the cove's own cluster is small, and widening the area would add open-beach transects from other clusters, not more sites like these. The placebo p values for the Z6 stretch are fragile: a few centimeters of difference in the tide correction change which sites it is compared with and move them between 0.5 and 0.03–0.07, so none is a settled result. The held-line screen (a transect that stops retreating while its neighbors keep going, 2017–19 to 2024–26) flags no transect; 3 transects retreat faster than their neighbors (T008, T052 and one in Z7c).

Z7b Middle northwest, the Z7b stretch · E0

This stretch, in Z7b Middle northwest, sits northwest of the cove, downdrift of the break: the net longshore drift on this coast runs NW (ERA5 wave angles against the local shoreline; the lagoon outlet southeast of the break is deflected northwestward on the dry-season images). If that holds, a wall there cannot starve the break of sand; an updrift wall could. The drift direction is modeled, with moderate confidence (where the sand goes); the field survey is what confirms it.

The wall on this stretch is too recent for the satellite record to show anything yet. Its forty-year rate (−0.31 m/yr) and its 1986–2026 gap against similar beaches (−0.12 m/yr) describe the beach over four decades; neither measures an effect of that wall. A before/after-control test there can detect a change of about 6.8 m now, 3.2 m by September 2027 and 2.5 m by September 2028. The smallest effect worth acting on is fixed in advance (A2) at the larger of 2 m and twice the per-transect uncertainty, so even two more years only just reach it. The lagged cross-correlation of transect anomalies shows no alongshore propagation at monthly resolution (87% of transect pairs peak at zero lag), so the drift direction rests on wave angles and the outlet, not on a traveling signal.

Decks on pillars · E0

The deck frontages in Z6 North beach are a separate exposure class: pile-supported decks scour locally and fix the back of the beach only once retreat reaches them; they block little sand alongshore.

Their transects are labeled and kept out of both the wall group and the control pool (so are 300 m on either side of every named property). They are reported as one zone-level group, the Z6 stretch; a combined rate for it has not been computed yet.

What is too small to see · E0

With the conservative per-image error (15.4 m) and about 10 independent clear months a year, a single transect can show a wall effect of about 17.9 m or more within two years of a dated build; averaging five transects along a stretch brings that to about 6.3 m (the Z6 central stretch) — and the smallest effect of interest is 2 m or twice the per-transect uncertainty, whichever is larger.

The forty-year retreat in Z6 North beach (about 28 m) is well above what the record can see; a wall's placement footprint of a few meters, the first years of end scour, or a change in beach width of a few meters are below it. Dry-beach width (waterline minus vegetation line, Sentinel-2) changed from 2017–19 to 2024–26 by +0.3 m at the Z6 central stretch relative to controls, +6.9 m at the Z7b stretch (the vegetation line there moved inland, which clearing for construction would also do), −4.6 to −6.4 m across the Z6 stretch. The placement loss each wall causes simply by occupying beach (Dugan & Hubbard 2010) is W = (crest height − toe height) ÷ tan(face slope) + toe apron, per meter of wall; it can be set against these numbers as soon as toe and crest heights are known. Survey lines every 10 m out to 100 m beyond each wall end are in the data file for the field survey: end scour (Griggs 2010) is the best-documented wall footprint, and at 10 m pixels the satellites cannot resolve it.

Ground truth the satellites cannot supply

5 · Limits

What this record cannot show

6 · Uncertainty

Every waterline carries its own error bar

Each shoreline is corrected to mean sea level by (tide + wave setup) ÷ beach slope. Setup follows Stockdon et al. (2006) with ERA5 wave height and mean period Tm at the image date, split by wave regime because one coefficient is biased on steep, coarse beaches (Atkinson et al. 2017): the waterline's own response gives groundswell 0.45 (measured); cyclone swell 0.69 (measured); mixed / wind sea 0.35 (Stockdon default). The effective slope comes from the waterline's response to tide: tanβ ≈ 0.047 (Sentinel-2 tide coefficient -21.4 ± 1.4 m per m), by region × season where they differ. Median parts of one waterline's σ: tide 1.5 m, slope 0.4 m, setup 1.4 m, swash 5.2 m, georegistration 8.0 m, whitewater at the waterline 1.4 m, extraction 2.0 m — 9.7 m in all. That internal figure is too optimiztic: benchmarks on high-energy beaches put single-image errors at 15–30 m (Vos et al. 2023), foam can push the line tens of meters seaward (Vos et al. 2019), and a steep reef-lined analog detected the right waterline only about half the time from Landsat and Sentinel-2 (Mikkelsen et al. 2026). So every number here uses a conservative σ that adds a 12 m method floor: median 15.4 m, 10th–90th percentile 14.1–18.2 m. Here, images with whitewater beyond the waterline (84% of Sentinel-2 transect-images) read −0.3 m different from those without — no measurable foam bias in this data, which the method floor covers anyway. Scatter is larger within 200 m of the creek and the lagoon outlet (turbid water) than 1 km away. No ground survey has validated these figures.

ConditionRobust SD of waterline scatter (m)Transect-images
Wave height (ERA5) · <1.0 m4.913,359
Wave height (ERA5) · 1.0–1.5 m5.476,428
Wave height (ERA5) · 1.5–2.0 m5.918,895
Wave height (ERA5) · ≥2.0 m6.42,172
Season · Dec–Feb4.939,930
Season · Mar–May5.733,492
Season · Jun–Aug7.213,801
Season · Sep–Nov5.323,631
Tide at overpass · < −0.15 m5.624,097
Tide at overpass · −0.15 to +0.15 m5.374,261
Tide at overpass · > +0.15 m6.212,496
Sensor · S26.048,480
Sensor · L55.320,609
Sensor · L75.84,681
Sensor · L85.024,866
Sensor · L94.912,218
Distance from creek / lagoon outlet · < 200 m6.49,765
Distance from creek / lagoon outlet · 200–500 m6.021,763
Distance from creek / lagoon outlet · 500–1000 m5.324,285
Distance from creek / lagoon outlet · ≥ 1000 m5.255,041
Sentinel-2 · whitewater beyond the waterline6.040,832
Sentinel-2 · no whitewater5.87,648
Caveats

Per-image waterline noise is about 6.8 m (Sentinel-2) and 6.7 m (Landsat) as a standard deviation around each transect's running median; no change smaller than about twice that is reported as a change.

The satellite waterline is the instantaneous land/water edge (wet sand, swash and foam included), not a surveyed contour. Tide and wave setup (Stockdon et al. 2006) are corrected; run-up/swash is carried as uncertainty, not removed.

The effective beach slope (tanβ ≈ 0.047, estimated from Sentinel-2 (tide coefficient of the rolling-residual regression)) comes from the waterline's own response to tide at overpass. Overpasses fall at about 10:30–11:10 local, so the tide sampled is a narrow slice (SD 0.157 m). Validation needs RTK profiles taken on Sentinel-2 overpass days.

Cloud cover makes the record dry-season heavy (November–May); wet-season storms are seen after the fact, often weeks later.

Landsat 5/7 geolocation is good to roughly half a pixel (~15 m) scene to scene; the 1986–2014 part of the long record is noisier than the Sentinel-2 part, and SLC-off Landsat 7 stripes (2003–2022) remove transects on many dates.

At 10–30 m a boulder revetment, a sand beach and a rock point can all hold a waterline; the imagery cannot say which is which. Wall locations and dates must come from the ground or from dated high-resolution imagery.

Property positions are Google Maps place pins (±30 m); the pins on the Z6 central stretch are ~12 m apart, so they share transects until the boundaries are surveyed.

Nothing here measures the sea floor. The surf zone is too turbid and too foamy for satellite-derived bathymetry; a changed bottom would show only indirectly, as a moved breaker line.

Sources and method

Approach: CoastSat-style shoreline extraction (Vos, Splinter, Harley, Simmons & Turner 2019, Environmental Modelling & Software 122:104528), re-implemented on Microsoft Planetary Computer cloud-optimized imagery with windowed reads of a 5.8 × 7.2 km box.

Script and artifact: scripts/analyze_shoreline.py → functions/api/_findings_shoreline.js (export FINDINGS_SHORELINE, served at /api/findings-shoreline): transects (with coordinates outside Z6 and Z7; zone level inside them), per-transect and per-reach rates with Monte Carlo intervals, annual medians, storm events and responses, the whitewater analysis, controls, synthetic controls, placebos, the exposure surface and the summary table. Page: scripts/build_shoreline_pages.py. Imagery is read on the fly and never stored in the repository.

Sources: Microsoft Planetary Computer STAC: sentinel-2-l2a, landsat-c2-l2 (USGS Collection 2 Level-2); ERA5-Wave hourly waves at the nearest offshore node (17.5°N, 102.0°W), reduced to daily (Copernicus Climate Change Service); HURDAT2 NE Pacific 1949–2025 (NOAA NHC); La Saladita harmonic tide model with nodal corrections (IOC Zihuatanejo gauge, 2013–2026); Google Maps place records for the property pins.

Analysis run: 27 September 2026.

Cite as: “Satellite shorelines 1986–2026 and whitewater 2015–2026 at La Saladita”, La Saladita Field Guide, lasaladita.com/findings/shoreline/, 2026-09-27.

Related